#AWW2018 Alicia Sometimes (poet)

- Author: Alicia Sometimes
- Poem: Kilonova
- #AWW2018
- Published: in The Best Australian Science Writing 2018
Introduction:
- This artist’s impression video shows how two tiny but very dense
- neutron stars merge via gravitational wave
- radiation and then explode as a kilonova.
- At its most basic, the gravitational wave discovery
- confirmed the existence of black holes, which is no mean feat.
- Thankfully, we have art – and poetry – to help us visualize
- ….what the discovery of gravitational waves will mean.
- Click HERE to watch the video ……and read the poem.
- You will be amazed how beautifully Alicia Sometimes
- …has explored the connection between
- …science & poetry & visual art.
Kilonova
We are detectives
We eavesdrop
Billions of years ago
two neutron stars
circle each other
desperate and breathless
finishing their last
pressing conversation
Remnants of once intense lives
cascade into a final spiral
until they embrace
smashing platinum
and gold into existence
a violent coalescence
outshining at least 100 billion suns
their collided mass
propagating gravitational waves
across the fabric of space
at light speed
gamma rays detected
only a moment after
We were watching
We were listening
We saw them encompass
each other completely
with their final words
rippling right through us
Last thoughts:
You can enjoy this poem on many levels:
Language:
- POV: first person plural, personal experiences
- We = scientists
- They = two neutron stars
- Personification: two star-crossed lovers
- breathless
- having conversation
- they embrace
- with their final words…
- Form: Line length, stanza breaks, white space
- mirror the emotion annd rhythm of its content.
- Title: Kilonova – a star that suddenly becomes thousands of times brighter
- Vocabulary: the poet uses words found in scientific articles
Scientific back round:
What is the science used in this poem? – gravitational waves
- Astronomers detected particles being accelerated by a
- rapidly rotating neutron star as it passed by the massive star it orbits.
2013:
- Source of a gravitational wave, created by
- merger of two neutron stars observed for the first time.
- This merger created a kilonova that ejects
- heavy elements such as gold and platinum into space.
2017:
- First detection of a collision of two neutron stars
- This produced a gravitational wave and a a short gamma-ray burst.
- The ripples in spacetime are known as gravitational waves.
- Several teams of scientists have managed to get
- the first observational proof for a kilonova.
- Of the 100 billion stars in our galaxy,
- less than 10 are known to be this type of
- …massive star with a neutron star orbiting around it.
Alicia Sometimes

#AWW 2018 The Enigmatic Mr. Deakin

- Author: Judith Brett
- Title: The Enigmatic Mr. Deakin
- Published: 2018
- Trivia: Winner National Biography Award 2018
- List of Challenges 2018
- Monthly plan
- #AWW2018 @AusWomenWriters
Conclusion:
- This is a book about the history, politics and philosophy
- of Australian liberals.
- It is Australian politics leading up to Deakin Government
- and his years as Prime Minister 1903-1908.
- As a brilliant speaker Deakin became one of the kind of people
- who are very good at playing the political game.
- Judtih Brett has done almost the impossible
- …make a shy, studious, religious man seem interesting.
- Remember this is not a literary biography but a political biography.
- It’s going to be full of elections, and policy making.
- So if you are not really interested in this topic
- ….the book will be a tough read.
Last thoughts:
- It is not easy to write a political biography
- It is not easy to condense an entire life into the form of a book
- …an interesting book.
- You have to find the right balance between
- historical fact and emotion to give the subject a pulse.
- I felt only a regular missed heartbeat.
- The author did not punch me with enough
- little details that make the character relatable.
- It is difficult to read the book you are writing
- as if you were the reader…instead of a writer.
- Perhaps that may have improved this book.
#AWW 2018 Atomic Thunder (NF)

- Author: E. Tynan
- Title: Atomic Thunder: The Maralinga Story
- Published: 2016
- Winner CHASS Award 2017 Australia Book Prize
- Winner Prime Minister’s Literary Award 2017 in the Australian History
- List of Challenges 2018
- Monthly plan
- #AWW2018 @AusWomenWriters
Who is Elizabeth Tynan?
- Elizabeth Tynan is a science writer and academic
- at the James Cook University in Queensland, Australia.
- She completed a PhD on aspects of British nuclear testing in Australia.
What is Atomic Thunder about?
- Britain wanted to join the nuclear club.
- Britain needed Australia’s geographic assets (testing ground)
- …and its distance from the British electorate.
- Britain conducted three atomic explosions at
- the Monte Bello Islands off the coast of Western Australia
- …and nine at Maralinga and Emu.
- This book chronicles the scandals that ensued:
- 1950 Australian prime minister Robert Menzies
- agreed to atomic tests without informing his government
- the overall levels and distribution of radioactivity
- …that wreaked havoc on Indigenous communities
- …and turned the land into a radioactive wasteland
- the uncovering of the extensive secrecy around British testing
- This book is the most comprehensive account of the whole saga.
- After the British departed they left an unholy mess behind.
Conclusion:
Strong point:
- Mw Tynan shows in the last chapters
- the transformation Australia society has endured.
- What a difference a generation makes
- …layers of secrecy and inertia are lifted!
- Investigative journalists and media are not
- ….interested in comforting the powerful
- No more stonewalling….
- The people of Australia demand accountability!
Quote: pg 290
- “Britain knew in the 1960’s that radioactivity at its former nucelar
- test site in Australia was worse than first thought.
- But it did not tell the Australians.“
Quote: pg 300
- “Australia in the 1950s and early 1960s was essentially
- ….an atomic banana republic…
- useful only for its resources…especially uranium and land.”
- Chilling and selfish attitude of Britain
- treating Australia as a lackey. Disgraceful
Last thoughts:
- The whole story is shocking but while I was reading
- chapter 9 Clean-ups and Cover-ups I put my hands
- over my lips in absolute horror.
- Clean up crews were working 12-hr shifts scooping
- up topsoil that was liberally
- …dotted with plutonium-contaminated fragments.
- No-one says any thing about this to George Owen (British Army recruit).
- After 5 months working at Maralinga he is discharged.
- Soon after he notices strange growths on his hands.
- This is plutonium-239….
- 1 millionth of a gram may be sufficient to
- cause lung cancer if inhaled.
- How much dust did Owen inhale?
- Speechless….
- #MustRead
- PS…I read it in one day…could NOT put it own!

Short stories: Like a House on Fire

- Author: Cate Kennedy
- Title: Like a House on Fire (15 short stories)
- Published: 2012
- Trivia: Shortlisted Stella Prize 2013
- Trivia: Winner Queensland Literary Award 2013 short story collection
- List Reading Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading planning
- #20BooksOfSummer
Notes:
Flexion – excellent – great last sentence – wife-husband relationship.
Ashes – excellent – great last sentence – son-mother and recently deceased father relationship.
Laminex and Mirrors – wonderful….very funny yet touching.
Narrator is an 18 yr cleaning girl in hospital who establishes a connection with an old dying man. The matron keeps a close eye on our young girl when she lingers too long with her new friend: ”matron calls her in a tone of permafrost…she snaps in an enraged whisper.” The old man is whisked away by the girl for a surprise hot steaming bath. ” Haven’t felt this way in years…weightless.” The old man also gets at the desired but forbidden cigarette from this young cleaner…he’s elated and says “Your blood is worth bottling.”
Tender – Honest, often-hilarious perspective of family life with the backdrop of an approaching appointment for the mother’s biopsy. She remains the Rock of Gibraltar for her family despite her fears.
Like a House on Fire – Hilarious description of father who is chief child-care provider (…suffering from lower back pain)…while he gets the Christmas decorations from the attic…puts the tree in the bucket with bricks to anchor it. The children are not in the Xmas mood but Dad says: “TV of off until every piece of tinsel is on the tree!” Family life and on Christmas eve and relationship with wife endearing and told in details we all see around the house! – Absolutely terrific!! It seems every story gets better and better! Bravo Cate Kennedy, this was the BEST story!
Conclusion:
- These are the notes I made about the first five short stories.
- It seem every story got increasingly better!
- Unfortunately….the rest of the stories failed to dazzle me.
- The first 5 stories tasted like a sparking glass of champagne
- ….they went straight to my head!
- The last 10 stories tasted like sparkling water
- … refreshing but without the ‘bubble buzz’.
Classic: Thea Astley

- Author: Thea Astley
- Title: Hunting the Wild Pineapple (8 stories)
- Published: 1979
- List Reading Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading planning
- #20BooksOfSummer
- #AWW2018
Introduction:
- I love a good short story.
- Usually I review just one story to post on this blog.
- W. Trevor and John Updike are favorites of mine,
- ..but a collection is the hardest thing to review.
- I want to give Thea Astley the attention she deserves and
- …have spent 4 days reading eight short stories!
Weak point:
- I felt only a few of the selections were real short stories.
- Instead Astely uses each ‘story’ as a continuation of
- Keith’s thoughts and adventures in Queensland.
- A short story must come to the point!
- A short story must reveal in 1st or 2nd
- paragraph the mood, theme and conflict.
- Astley fails on this point.
- In The Curate Breaker there was a clear conflict
- between the Catholic priest and Anglican minister.
- The resolution was believable and touching.
- This story made this reader pause and think.
- #Bravo
Conclusion
- I read these eight stories and have reviewed four.
- The first story was a disappointment and
- …I had to push myself to read the rest of the book.
- I was expecting a short story and got what sounded
- …like the exposition of a novel!
- So you’ve been warned: the first story is a dud.
- But I kept reading…giving Astely a chance to improve!
4 REVIEWS I’ll let you discover the rest yourself!
North: Some Compass Readings: Eden
- Setting: Carins
- Title: refers to the first two sentences:
- “Let me draw you a map…put it just north of 20 and 146 east…
- sea bitten rind of coast…limbo for those who’ve lost direction.”
- Parents: Iris and Bernard are exact opposites:
- Iris: gorges on horoscopes, sports a lucky color and
- it always seems to be the Ides of March.
- Bernard: jocular, jaunty and tips his son an unsmiling
- wink as he he rattles his newspaper busily.
- Narrator: Keith Leverson
- Note: Iris, Bernard and Keith are
- characters are from Astley’s book The Slow Natives.
- A suburban couple, Iris and Bernard,
- …have drifted into the shallows of middle-aged boredom.
- Their fourteen-year-old son, Keith is a stranger.
Plot:
- Fourteen-year-old son, Keith is now
- middle-aged, thinning blond hair and
- ..has lost one leg in a car accident
- …that was central in the book The Slow Natives.
- Keith sets out on a journey from Carins
- to Falls Gorge on the Kuranda railway.
- Keith/Astley rants about the influx of lean, arrogantly young
- Balmain and South Yarra drop-outs,
- the new urban trendies and
- the middle-aged straights trying to adopt the patois and local dress.
- Theme: landscape is beautiful in Queensland
- ….but you get more magic from strangers (the misfits).
Weak point: allusions
- The use of allusions in Astley’s novels is
- one of the elements of her style that I enjoy reading.
- But in her short stories I think she has
- overreached herself and lost much of her focus.
Weak point: Tone
- The tone achieved by the use of allusions
- shifted from imaginative in her novels...
- to pedantic in the short stories.
Conclusion:
- This was NOT an easy read.
- Astley starts her story in the present but
- flashbacks to a month ago, then yesterday,
- …then the present again.
- It was hard to follow.
- The author makes it even more complex….
- by filling the story with too many allusions.
- Brilliant writing….but not a well-balanced story.
- Thea Astely’s novels? TOP!
- Thea Astely’s short stories? Not her strong point!
- Allusion: poem Trade Winds by J. Masefield
- Allusion: Shakespeare’s Hamlet
- Allusion: to Virgil “Sera comans, Iris” (the late blooming…)
- Allusion: D.H. Lawrence poem Green:
- “…the gorge is evaporating in green light,
- green into greeness as Lawrence might have said…”
- ... Astely assumes we all know who Lawrence is.
The Curate Breaker
Conclusion:
- This was a normal short story….a pleasure to read
- …with a beginning, middle and end.
- The story centers around an insanely bitter conflict
- between the Roman Catholic priest and the Anglican canon.
- Father Rassini and Canon Morrow are at odds
- …but their lives are heartbreakingly parallel.
- The tragedy is….neither the priest nor the canon
- see their uncharitable behavior.
- Canon Morrow flatters and shields his ego from blame
- when we make mistakes (berating his wife…severely, angrily)
- because he is doing God’s work.
- Father Rassini observes this behavior and is appalled.
- But this suave man of God realizes he is no better than Canon Morrow.
- Father Rassini has callously ill-treated his father
- …snapping and shouting at him when the elderly parent falters.
- Father Rassini suddenly leaves the house after seeing
- his frail, grey parent shelling peas for the evening meal.
- Father Rassini must spend some quiet time with God,
- asking Him to show him where he needs to change.
Hunting the Wild Pineapple
Conclusion:
- I was hoping to have a great time enjoying
- Astley’s humor and finding out what
- in heaven’s name the wild pineapple meant.
- My enthusiasm waned.
- Why do bad souffles happen to good cooks?
- Why do dull stories….happen to good writers?
- This story started out with Astley’s keen observation of bored
- people at a tropical Bed and Breakfast
- …where the pink gin, vodkas on ice
- …and stingers kept the guests
- in a permanent ‘happy-hour’.
- There was some sexual tension arising among
- B&B owner, guests and two plantation workers (gay and bi).
- But nothing that made the story shine.
- Hunting the Wild Pineapple was a hoax to
- …take bored and slightly tipse guests
- …on a wild goose chase.
- This story had so much potential
- ..and I hoped it would entertain me as much as
- Boat Load of Home Folk,
- but this short story sadly #Collapsed.
A Northern Belle
Conclusion:
- Astley uses no alcohol, no allusions only Clarice’s tears and embedded fears:
- Fear black men instilled by her mother
- Fear of sins of the flesh instilled by the nuns, Mother Suplice.
- Irony: her mother was determined her daughter Clarice would marry well
- ….but her only true love was Bixer, her dog.
- Weak point:
- There is no real epiphany, no redemptive moment.
- Just a sad life that ends with a traumatized unmarried
- …50 yr old woman….screaming.
- #Disappointing, lacking imagination.

Victorian Premier’s Literary Award Drama 2018

Nisha and Yvette
- Playwright: Michele Lee (Asian-Australian playwright based in Melbourne)
- Title: Rice (3 acts)
- Published: 2017
- Trivia: Winner Victorian Premier’s Award Drama 2018
- Trivia: Winner Queensland Premier’s Award Drama 2016-2017
- #20BooksOfSummer
Introduction:
Understanding characters in plays allows the reader to relate to
different situations, backgrounds, and cultures.
Asian-Australian office cleaner Yvette clashes with
ambitious Australian-Indian Nisha corporate executive officer in multinational.
A lasting friendship begins.….
What is the play about?
- Michele Lee writes plays about women of colour.
- Rice is about an ambitious, self-obsessed Indian executive
- Nisha Gupta (28 yr) working for Golden Fields Company.
- She is the granddaughter of a West Bengal immigrant.
- She is ‘second in charge’ of an agricultural company.
- Yvette Tang (61 yr) is a Chinese immigrant.
- She is a single-mother, one daughter.
- She is an office cleaner.
- Yvette and Nisha.… multicultural women
- …making their way in modern Australia.
Metaphor:
- Metaphor: Nisha is on the top floor of the building
- ….successful.
- Metaphor: Yvette is in the basement of the building
- .…struggling with a menial job.
Strong point:
- Michele Lee uses parallels throughout the play to show
- us the connection between Yvette and Nisha.
- It took me 2 readings to discover them all!
Yvette and Nisha: similarities
- both work in Golden Fields building
- both have emotional ties to family – yvette/daughter; Nisha/grandmother
- both are ‘putting on an act’
- Yvette = “little old cleaner victim” – Nisha = “Your corporate act”
- both are businesswomen
- Yvette: Import.”You think I import plastics? (imports Prada knock-offs)
- Nisha: I’m E.O. of Golden Fields. I’m strategic!
- both live in suburbs of Melbourne
- ….but at opposite sides. Yvette: Eltham – Nisha: Werribee
Strong point:
- The ‘tit-for-tat’ dialogue between Nisha and Yvette…
- It snaps, crackles and pops off the page.
- Nisha: You’re the one with the vacuum cleaner. End of story
- Yvette: Not the end
- Nisha: Chinese cleaner
- Yvette: Indian princess
- Nisha: You’re a cleaner
- Yvette: You’re a baby
- Yvette: I empty. (complained that Nisha left her rubbish on desk an not in bin)
- Nisha: Both my bins are full. Nothing on the table. Happy?
Friendship:
- They’re from different cultures, different generations
- …but a bond develops between Yvette and Nisha
- Yvette: Act 1 Very fussy. Very big bitch. Hope she get fired
- Yvette: Act 3 (…she mumurs) “I will miss you little shadow.“
- Nisha: Act 1 I stay. I eat. I make a mountain of rubbish for you.
- Nisha: Act 3 You tell me what to do…Well I pretty much did, ok?
- Yvette: Act 3 “All you want is me to say you are right.”
- Nisha: Act 3 “Say something about me. Tell me. Judge me“
Echoes: of friendship
- Act 1:
- Nisha “This is the part of the story where we first meet.”
- Yvette: “This the part where we eat.” (rice together….)
- Rice is an ancient symbol of wealth,
- success, fertility and good health.
- It is powerful.
- Act 3:
- Yvette “This is the part where we leave together.
- This is the part where we go.”
Yvette changes:
- Plays the victim …(act 2)
- …groveling at the feet of David Egan, son of CEO of Coles company.
- Does not express her opinion…”But not everything I think I have to say.”
- Change:
- Act 3 we see a ‘re-born’ Yvette with a voice!
- A voice in sync with the new generation….her daughter Sheree!
- “Mr. David Egan. Fuck you.
- “Coles is evil and the system is broken.
- And that is all I have to say to you. Mr. David Egan.”
Nisha changes:
- In the first two acts Nisha is a corporate ‘high-roller.”
- She has a better grasp of the world.
- She is is a little brighter than the next person.
- She is a high stakes player who is willing
- to place large bets and take risks.
- She is brokering a rice deal with biggest retainer in the world.
- Plot: Nisha’s fatal overseas
- business trip to sell rice to the Indians.
- “Any day now this phone is going to sing.”
- …this is game-changing, history-breaking.”
- Change:
- Act 3 “I don’t do anything special. (E.O) It’s a bullshit title.
- Nisha once demanded Yvette clean….end of story.
- Now Nisha helps Yvette empty bins,
- …squashes the rubbish down and adds in new bin liners.
- She’s about to be fired….the rise and fall of Nisha.
Strong point:
- Michele Lee allows Yvette a
- heightened level of knowledge about Nisha.
- The older generation may not have
- a Masters degree from University of Sydney
- but Yvette can teach Nisha.
- Yvette shows her that she should not be afraid of
- shame…of failing…not being perfect.
- Yvette has learned that the hard way.
Nisha and Yvette help each other:
- Courage is the feeling we need to bring to the surface
- if we want to change things.
- Nisha helps Yvette find her voice and the courage to quit.
- The courage to be closer to her daughter.
- Yvette helps Nisha to see the world from ‘street level’
- and realize how lucky she is.
- “You need help? Huh? Why? You are young,
- you have a job. Look at you.
Strong point: coded words, foreign languages…multicultural
- Echoes: “Wo hui xiang nie de, xiao yingzi”
- This is the thread that connects Yvette to Nisha
- “I will miss you little shadow”.
- Echoes: “Tini bijoyer sathei aasen.”
- This is the thread that connects Nisha to Yvette
- and her grandmother.
- “She moves with victory.”
Valerie: voice that makes you stop and think…comic relief.
- Valerie is a 60+ Russian who
- …is the cleaning service supervisor of Yvette.
- She is only in the first act…but has something to say!
- Valerie and Yvette represent the older generation.
- How is that fussy bitch? (Nisha)
- Fuck you time sheet! (cleaners trained for 2 minute only office clean)
- Why is this world worse than when we came into it?
- Don’t look so tragic. Life is shit. Company training say so.
Theme: mother vs daughter
- Yvette Chinese cleaner vs Sheree political activist/law student.
- These are the emotional scenes
- a mother and a daughter.
- Yvette and Sheree are from different generations.
- Act 1:
- “In this world you bring me shame, but I only have you…
- …you only have me.”
- They are exact opposites.
- Act 2:
- Sheree wants trouble,
- to step on corporate toes, be a modern-day martyr.
- Yvette wants to keep a low profile… nose to the grindstone.
- Yvette has learned it does not pay ‘to make waves.’
- Act 2:
- Mother and daughter clash.
- Sheree speaks her mind: “You only do things for yourself” ….
- Yvette: “Your Ma, always, always, everything to help you, keep you….”
- In Act 3 I found the most poignant remarks by Yvette:
- “Thank you for being mine.”
What is different in this play?
- Characters: There are 11 characters in the play.
- but just two actresses on the stage.
- The women can change their voices, accents
- and stage lighting (according to the stage directions)
- helps differentiate the characters.
- TWO protagonists: Nisha and Yvette
- story lines are closely intertwined,
- …both in the plot and the theme.
- Structure: NOT the classic 3 act play
- focus on 1 character – conflict-driven –
- cause and effect….progressively raising the stakes.
- This is OPEN MODEL:
- uses parallel action, echoes
- events linked by coincidence
- ending, instead of resolution
Conclusion: my thoughts
Note: I have learned that when I read a play I know I will absorb only the basics during the first reading: characters, setting, structure of the play. The best way to read a play is just before bedtime. Then I try to retell mysef what the play is about. In the morning I have new thoughts about conflicts, parallels, repetition of phrases (echoes). Reading a play is more difficult than reading a novel!
Note: This play is a brilliant piece or writing that you will not realize if you just read it once. The subplots are good (Graeme, Tom, Johnny Song) but concentrate on the main character’s dialogues of Nisha and Yvette. Try to hear….what is NOT being said! Michele Lee has deservedly won prestigious prizes: Victorian Premier’s Award Drama 2018 and Queensland Premier’s Award Drama 2016-2017.
Note: Reading a play on Kindle…is not as much fun. In the book I can make notes, highlight dialogue. Yes, I can do that on Kindle…..but I love having the script in front of me. It is an intimate reading of a playwrights hard work! It is so much fun to dissect a play.
Australian ‘new to me’ or slang:
- ASOS: – global fashion place for 20-somethings
- The Iconic: Australian/New Zealand fashion place for 20-somethings
- bogan – One of minimal intelligence, standards and fasion sense. Located in Australia, found in caravan parks, housing commission, the pub or Centrelink queues. (Urban dictionary)

Mackellar: How to Get There

- Author: M. Mackellar
- Title: How to Get There
- Published: 2014
- Genre: memoir
- List of Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading plan
Introduction:
- I read an essay by Maggie Mackellar last year in
- The Best Australian Essays 2016
- …and was very impressed.
- Mackellar has had a tough life
- …death of young husband, single mother… but she is resilient.
- I want to read how she sets out her new life in Tasmania.
Conclusion:
- I had my reservations about the book in the first few chapters.
- Mackellar was describing her new relationship with Jim and
- the move to Tasmania in micro-details.
- But soon after reading the “inner thoughts’ pages between chapters
- …I was drawn into Mackellar’s world.
- “I promised myself I would never trust again.
- How does anyone ever learn to love again.”
- Through every small opening in life
- …through rips and tears and tatters….life pours.
- Mackellar: “I’ve raised these kids,
- I deserve some companionship, some love.
- I’ve done this on my own for 10 years.”
- Mackeller struggles to set down roots in Tasmania:
- a new love….compromise chips away at identity
- writer’s block…
- homesickness..the acid rain that leaches into happiness.
- “Home, I must learn to say home.” (ch 6)
- This was a great read in which
- …Mackellar pours her heart out
- …and I mean that in a good way.
- “Sitting in the quiet I also fear my own inadequacy
- …to be the woman all these people need me to be.”
- #Insightful
Last thoughts:
- I dare you to read this book
- …especially the last 3 chapters + epilogue without
- feeling emotional, a welling up in your eyes
- …..as you try to reach out to Maggie Mackellar.
- I wanted to tell her
- …your book? your life?
- …..Job well done!
Wineglass Bay, Tasmania
- This is the view Mackellar had during
- …her few days of solitude writing.
- This is one of the most beautiful beaches in the world!

Essays: The Australian Face (editor Catriona Menzies)

- Title: The Australian Face: Essays from The Sydney Review of Books
- Published: 2017
- Editor: Catriona Menzies Pike – Editor Sydney Review of Books.
- She holds a PhD in English literature from the University of Sydney.
- Editor: James Ley – Professional literary critic.
- He holds a PhD in English literature from the University of Western Sydney.
What is the Sydney Review of Books?
The Sydney Review of Books was launched in 2013 out of frustration at the diminishing public space for Australian criticism on literature.
What is this book about?
To celebrate the Sydney Review of Books first five years online Ms Menzies and J. Ley have selected the ‘cream of the crop‘ out of more than 500 published essays over the years. This anthology contains essays on Australian fiction, poetry and non-fiction.
What are essays for?
They are for thinking about things that need to be thought about. This book highlights several popular Australian authors ( H. Garner, A. Wright, M.B. Clarke and Les Murray (…could win Nobel Prize!). But I enjoyed discovering a forgotten Australian poet, Lesbia Harford, the literature scholar John Frow (impressive credentials!) and Moya Costello.
This book not only reveals the mainstream writers….but also extremely talented essayists like Jeff Sparrow, Julieanne Lamond and Ben Etherington.
Here are some of my notes:
#ExcellentEssay: Gut Instinct by James Ley
- James Ley is not only editor but has contributed a
- brilliant essay about H. Garner’s House of Grief.
- He examines Garner’s style in this book about a slow
- grinding process of two court cases the
- provide the narrative spine of the book.
#ExcellentEssay: The Brain Feign by Ben Etherington
- Ben Etherington’s essay was a refreshing critical look at a number of
- Australian book reviewers
- ….offering a ‘chorus of weak cheers’ about recent publications.
- Etherson’s complaint in his essay is that critics
- summarise the content, recapitulate the blurb,
- describe the author’s reputation but none of the critics work
- to demonstrate WHY the novel deserves a prize or not!
#NotAFan: Sings for the Soul by Anthony Ullmann
- Unfortunately I gave up on Anthony Uhlmann’s essay.
- This my be very well MY problem…and not reflection on the writer.
- But read the essay yourself…and let me know what YOU think!
#ExcellentEssay: Render It Barely – Jeff Sparrow
- Impressive essay by Jeff Sparrow about a forgotten Australian poet
- Lesbia Harford.
- I knew nothing about Jeff Sparrow or Lesbia Harford.
- Ms Harford’s poems are worth reading
- …especially her love poems and factory poems
- …but Sparrow emphasizes
- that they should be read with the
- …knowledge of what was happening in
- Australian society (rise of Marxism and the Communist Party,
- the working class demanding rights, the world WWI and
- in the poet’s own life (lovers Guido Baracchi and Katie Lush).
- I am eager to read more articles written by Jeff Sparrow!
- Jeff Sparrow is a writer, editor, and broadcaster.
- He writes a fortnightly column for The Guardian and was the contributes
- regularly to many other Australian and international publications.
- He was the immediate past editor of literary journal Overland.
- I enjoy is style:
- …he does not want to preach…. he wants to teach.
#ExcellentEssay: The Australian Face by Julieanne Lamond
- Ms Lamond discusses The Barracuda by Christos Tsjolkas.
- She compares it to the author’s popular novel The Slap.
- Australia in The Slap: why hatred can hold communities together.
- Australia in The Barracuda: shows the absurdity of
- …the idea that Australia is a classless society.
- Sounds like these books are filled with some ‘fireworks’!
Last thoughts:
- This is one of the best anthologies of essays I’ve ever read
- Another collection of eassys I enjoyed
- …was Zadie Smith’s Feel Free.
- I’m including The Australian Face review on the
- Australian Women Writers Challenge. #AWW2018
- I feel Ms Catriona Menzies-Pike should enjoy some praise for
- guiding The Sydney Review of Books and together with J. Ley
- …selecting some great pieces of writing.
- Discover the rest of the essays yourself!
- #GreatRead

Christy Collins: The End of Seeing

- Author: C. Collins
- Title: The End of Seeing
- Published: 2015
- List of Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading plan
Conclusion:
- I am aggressively attacking my TBR list
- I found Christy Collins’ The End of Seeing.
- I have NO idea why I bought this book or who Ms Collins is.
- So I went into the novel(la) with a clean slate.
- The first three chapters captured my attention.
- Ms Collins gave us the small details of what Ana feels
- while trying to come to grips with her grief (death of child, partner).
- After 50%… I realized this is not a book I am enjoying.
- Ms Collins places Ana’s past life with partner and baby as
- one of the main subplots…it almost overshadows the rest of the book.
- IMO I would have preferred less baby and more intrigue…
- about the missing photo journalist (partner) and people trafficking.
Last thoughts:
- Sometimes a book does not click with me.
- The style is wrong….the taste not my own.
- Others have praised this book and
- …that is their right to express an opinion.
- We as readers also agree to disagree at times.
- But reading what I dislike helps me refine what it is I value.
- It is always a win-win situation.
- Who knew I would like the horror genre was
- …it not for taking a chance on Aletheia by J.S. Breukelaar?
YA: Jenna’s Truth

- Author: N.L. King
- Title: Jenna’s Truth
- Published: 2016
- List Reading Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading planning
Strong point:
- Ms King expresses the emotions of a young girl
- that feel universal…timeless. We all at one point
- have felt being an outsider in school….it hurts.
Strong point:
- The devil is in the details.…and Ms King knows that!
- I rarely read in stories about women’s perfume.
- People I remember from school had signature fragrances.
- It was your ‘calling card’… L’Air du Temps, Blue Grass, Miss Dior.
- Jenna can finally sit next to Tina
- ….the in-crowd… and whiff her perfume.
Strong point:
- Ms. Nadia has translated a tragic story of Amanda Todd
- into a poignant book.
- The book is enriched with teaching notes and
- discussion questions.
- Sometimes young people don’t know how
- tell people they are being bullied.
- Ms. King has added a ‘need help’ page with
- addresses and phone numbers children can call.
Conclusion:
- Here I am a 60+’er reading about the
- pain of being an outsider (Jenna) in high-school.
- Ms King describes details that STILL resonate
- …taking me back to the 1960’s.
- It seems then and now
- ….the feeling when someone saves
- you a seat in class is “like basking in the sun” !
- And yes, I agree with Ms King and her character Jenna
- “Physics never made any sense.“
- Of course Insta page, selfies and Snapchat are new
- …but that just adds to the 21st C feel of the book.
- This book deserves the praise it has reaped.
- Young girls should be aware…
- There is so much more to life
- …being snubbed or bad-mouthed,
- and worst of all cyber-bullying by puerile girls.
- #Heartbreaking
Last thoughts:
- I’ll tell you a two secrets….
- I had this book flown in from Australia!
- I read the book aloud to my cats.
- It was great fun and I could put on my snarky voice.
- But this does not dampen
- …the effect the book had on me.
- So young, so unhappy with life
- ….so tragic, I can hardly imagine
- …the pain Jenna/Amanda Todd went through.
- #Cyberbulling must stop.
