Essays: The Australian Face (editor Catriona Menzies)

- Title: The Australian Face: Essays from The Sydney Review of Books
- Published: 2017
- Editor: Catriona Menzies Pike – Editor Sydney Review of Books.
- She holds a PhD in English literature from the University of Sydney.
- Editor: James Ley – Professional literary critic.
- He holds a PhD in English literature from the University of Western Sydney.
What is the Sydney Review of Books?
The Sydney Review of Books was launched in 2013 out of frustration at the diminishing public space for Australian criticism on literature.
What is this book about?
To celebrate the Sydney Review of Books first five years online Ms Menzies and J. Ley have selected the ‘cream of the crop‘ out of more than 500 published essays over the years. This anthology contains essays on Australian fiction, poetry and non-fiction.
What are essays for?
They are for thinking about things that need to be thought about. This book highlights several popular Australian authors ( H. Garner, A. Wright, M.B. Clarke and Les Murray (…could win Nobel Prize!). But I enjoyed discovering a forgotten Australian poet, Lesbia Harford, the literature scholar John Frow (impressive credentials!) and Moya Costello.
This book not only reveals the mainstream writers….but also extremely talented essayists like Jeff Sparrow, Julieanne Lamond and Ben Etherington.
Here are some of my notes:
#ExcellentEssay: Gut Instinct by James Ley
- James Ley is not only editor but has contributed a
- brilliant essay about H. Garner’s House of Grief.
- He examines Garner’s style in this book about a slow
- grinding process of two court cases the
- provide the narrative spine of the book.
#ExcellentEssay: The Brain Feign by Ben Etherington
- Ben Etherington’s essay was a refreshing critical look at a number of
- Australian book reviewers
- ….offering a ‘chorus of weak cheers’ about recent publications.
- Etherson’s complaint in his essay is that critics
- summarise the content, recapitulate the blurb,
- describe the author’s reputation but none of the critics work
- to demonstrate WHY the novel deserves a prize or not!
#NotAFan: Sings for the Soul by Anthony Ullmann
- Unfortunately I gave up on Anthony Uhlmann’s essay.
- This my be very well MY problem…and not reflection on the writer.
- But read the essay yourself…and let me know what YOU think!
#ExcellentEssay: Render It Barely – Jeff Sparrow
- Impressive essay by Jeff Sparrow about a forgotten Australian poet
- Lesbia Harford.
- I knew nothing about Jeff Sparrow or Lesbia Harford.
- Ms Harford’s poems are worth reading
- …especially her love poems and factory poems
- …but Sparrow emphasizes
- that they should be read with the
- …knowledge of what was happening in
- Australian society (rise of Marxism and the Communist Party,
- the working class demanding rights, the world WWI and
- in the poet’s own life (lovers Guido Baracchi and Katie Lush).
- I am eager to read more articles written by Jeff Sparrow!
- Jeff Sparrow is a writer, editor, and broadcaster.
- He writes a fortnightly column for The Guardian and was the contributes
- regularly to many other Australian and international publications.
- He was the immediate past editor of literary journal Overland.
- I enjoy is style:
- …he does not want to preach…. he wants to teach.
#ExcellentEssay: The Australian Face by Julieanne Lamond
- Ms Lamond discusses The Barracuda by Christos Tsjolkas.
- She compares it to the author’s popular novel The Slap.
- Australia in The Slap: why hatred can hold communities together.
- Australia in The Barracuda: shows the absurdity of
- …the idea that Australia is a classless society.
- Sounds like these books are filled with some ‘fireworks’!
Last thoughts:
- This is one of the best anthologies of essays I’ve ever read
- Another collection of eassys I enjoyed
- …was Zadie Smith’s Feel Free.
- I’m including The Australian Face review on the
- Australian Women Writers Challenge. #AWW2018
- I feel Ms Catriona Menzies-Pike should enjoy some praise for
- guiding The Sydney Review of Books and together with J. Ley
- …selecting some great pieces of writing.
- Discover the rest of the essays yourself!
- #GreatRead

Feel Free Essays by Zadie Smith

- Author: Zadie Smith
- Title: Feel Free (31 essays)
- Published: 2018
- List Reading Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading planning
- #DealMeIn2018 Bibliophilopolis
Fences: A Brexit Diary
- This essay is about a topical issue: Brexit.
- But was written in August 2016 and much has happened since.
- The facts: The UK will leave the EU by
- automatic operation of international law on 29 March 2019.
- The UK government does not know what it wants
- …and there is no UK Brexit policy worth the name.
- Working-class Brits voted without understanding the stakes
- …and fell back on their inherited fear of England’s invasion by foreigners.
- Despite the fact that many people in London there are
- …multicultural and cross-class aspects in their lives
- …...that is actually represented by their staff —
- nannies, cleaners, people who pour their coffee and who drive the cabs.
- The painful truth is the fences are being raised all over London.
- Conclusion:
- Smith lambasts wealthy London.
- ” We walk past ‘them‘ very often in the street and get into their cabs
- …and eat their food in their ethnic restaurants
- …but the truth is that more often than not they are
- …NOT in our schools, social circles, and very rarely enter our houses
- …– unless they’ve come to work on our endlessly remodeled kitchens.”
- Excellent essay
In the Audience (very good!)
- Generation Why? – review of the movie “Social Network” (Zuckerberg and Facebook).
- Seems surreal to read this review by Zadie Smith while
- Facebook is in the midst of turmoil (Facebook vs Cambridge Analytics scandal).
- Zadie Smith quit Facebook 2 months after she started.
- She admits FB has been the greatest distraction from work she has ever had.
- In FB life is turned into a database and this is degradation.
- We use the FB software to behave in a certain, superficial way toward others.
- We know what we are doing ‘IN’ the software
- ….but we don’t know what the software is doing to us?
- Zadie Smith quotes Lanier a software expert:
- ” be attentive to the software into which we are ‘locked in’.
- Is it really fulfilling our needs?
- When a human being becomes a set of data on a
- …website like Facebo0k, he or she is reduced
- …our networked selves don’t look more free
- …they look more owned.
- It is scary reading this essay published in November 2010
- …8 years ago…and feeling it could have been written today!
- It does not matter who you are, as long as you make ‘choices’.
- Zadie Smith gets nostalgic at the end of the essay
- “I’m dreaming of a Web that caters to a kind of
- person who no longer exists” …a private person.
- NOTE: I have DELETED Facebook and TWITTER
- …a waste of my reading time!
The House that Hova Built
- Starting The House That Hova Built. (2012, New York Times Magazine).
- Reading this in 2018 we already know Jay-Z
- will have an extra marital affair (2013 – 2015).
- His wife made the 6th best selling album
- …by a woman in all time “Lemonade” in 2016.
- Beyoncé reveals explicitly her progress through the discovery,
- detonation and aftermath of the affair.
- Album is divided into chapters: Intuition, Denial, Anger, Forgiveness, Redemption.
- Rapper Jay-Z mentioned in an interview with Zadie Smith:
- And when it comes to talent,
- ‘You just never know– there is no guage.
- You don’t see when it’s empty.’
- IRONY: Speaking about his then 4 month old daughter, Ivy Blue,
- “She doesn’t have to be tough […]
- …she has to be respectful and be a moral person“.
- Hmm…just like her daddy!
Brother from Another Mother
- I had to look up who Key & Peele are.
- I needed to watch some Key & Peele on You Tube!
- The first two seasons of Key & Peele on Comedy Central
- ..received positive reviews, maintaining a score 74 of 100.
- The third season of Key & Peele received
- …critical acclaim, receiving a score of 82 of 100!
- The series won a Peabody Award in 2013
- “for its stars and their creative team’s inspired
- …satirical riffs on our racially divided and racially conjoined culture.
- THANK YOU Zadie Smith…I finally discovered Key & Peele!
Some Notes on Attunement – very personal, touching
- I loved this essay.
- There was a quote that made me stop and think about
- …my determination to find out ‘What Makes Poetry Tick.
- I think Zadie Smith has given the key I was looking for.
- Quote:
- “Sometimes it is when you stop trying to understand
- …the new art that you become more open to it.
- Put simply: You need to lower your defenses.
Flaming June
Zadie Smith starts her essay “I’m trying to think of the first bits of art I ever saw.” Now that is a good question. My Dad had some prints in his den of Revolutionary War 1776 soldiers hanging around a cannon. I don’t consider that art. But in my uncle’s house there was one painting (print) by Renoir I remember...I liked her hat.

But Zadie Smith in this very short essay tells us which poster she choose to hang in her college apartment: Flaming June by Leighton. From now on she was not going to pinch pennies like her father or take up political commitments like her mother. No, Zadie was going to live for art! “I’m going to spend three years on a sofa thinking about truth and art…” “I was going to live for love and art and food[…]….and sleep, lots of sleep!”

Crazy They Call Me: On Looking at Jerry Dantzic’s Photos of Billie Holiday

- In this essay (New Yorker, 06.03.2017) you inhabit the world of Billie Holiday.
- Zadie Smith is writing the story from the singer’s perspective.
- “…after the clapping dies down,
- …there’s simply no one and nothing to be done.”
- “…you’re grateful for your little dog…”
- “A dog don’t cheat, a dog don’t lie.”
- “This little dog and you? Soulmates. Where you been all my life?”
- “You never sing anything after….’Strange Fruit“
- This song, written by Abel Meeropol and performed
- by many artists (but most notably, Billie Holiday and Nina Simone,)
- …is a dark and profound song about
- …the lynching of African Americans in the
- …Southern United States during the Jim Crow Era.
- In the lyrics, black victims are portrayed as “strange fruit,”
- …as they hang from trees, rotting in the sun, blowing in the wind,
- …and becoming food for crows upon being burned.
- It was a protest song that Billie Holiday
- ..very bravely performed under grave threats and at high personal cost.
- THE BEST ESSAY
- Essay: A Bird of Few Words by Zadie Smith (The New Yorker, 19.06.2017)
- I thought this essay was going back and forth
- ..describing the art of Lynette Yiadom Boakye (British- Ghanaian artist) and
- …then comparing it to the comments of the critics.
- But Smith went in another direction.
- Boakye creates compelling character studies of people who don’t exist.
- The paintings are of people with no name.
- Boakye can finish a portrait in 1 day…
- …and Smith sighs from a novelist’s point of view both the
- ..speed and clarity of Boakye is humbling.
- This painting I found light as if the person was about to take flight!

- But this painting just was full of ‘color politics’ and
- …shows Boakye’s talents and Smith’s insightful interpretation.
- “Mercy over Matter” a man holds a bird on this finger.
- Notice “…the underplumage: those jewel-like greens and
- …purples and reds you can spot
- beneath the oil-slick surface of certain bird-feathered birds.
- …the man’s jacket magically displays this same underplumage;
- …so does his skin; so does the bird.
- He is often thought of as a nothing, a cipher.
- But he has layers upon layers upon layers.“

Essay: Dancing Lessons for Writers
- Author: Zadie Smith
- Title essay: Dancing Lessons for Writers
- Book: Feel Free (collection essays)
- Published: February 2018
- Chores and grocery shopping are done!
- Now I have time to read…Zadie Smith’s essay before my coffee break.
- Dance Lessons for Writers
- I see directly that this essay is laying the groundwork
- …for Smith’s newest book Swing Time (2016)
- She wants to investigate the
- …connection between writing and dancing.
- Quote:
- “What can an art of words take from the art that needs none?”
- This essay was written 29.10.2016 in The Guardian.
- Her book was written in 2015 and released 1 month after this article.
- Dance lessons for writers would include:
- position, attitude, rhythm and style.
- Smith makes a wonderful comparison between
- Fred Astaire (free-floating, aloof, appears to skim across the surface) and
- Gene Kelly (low center of gravity, bends his knees, hunkers down).
- Now Smith lays this comparison over language!
- Gene Kelly: commonsense language, language of TV,
- …supermarket, the advert, newspapers, the government.
- GK- type writer? One whose natural talents are
- ….combined with hard-earned skills. (Raymond Carver)
- Fred Astaire: (poetry in motion)
- FA- type writer? One who barely puts a toe in
- …daily public conversation, prefers the
- …literary language a literal aristocrat. (Vladimir Nabokov)
- Smith goes on to find what the
- …writer can learn from the dance moves of
- Michael Jackson and Prince.
- Prince is an ode...try to capture a passing sensation.
- Jackson is a graphic novel, all very visible
- …and sometimes ALL CAPS.
- But there are many more comparisons
- …this is a essay worth your reading time!
- #MustRead
Essay: Fair Australia Prize 2017
- Author: Julian Bull
- Title: Aussie Albert
- Published: 2017
- Trivia: Read essay in link Overland Literary Review
- Trivia: Julian Bull studied natural resources management and
- landscape architecture at the Universities of Adelaide and Melbourne.
Conclusion:
- What do you say when an essay leaves you speechless?
- Julian Bull gives a snapshot of Albert Namatjira
- …and a glimpse at the injustices befalling Indigenous Australians
- who are still denied a voice in
- …determining their destiny in contemporary Australia.

Julian Bull uses this photo to show the reader Aussie Albert’s situation:
“…Albert, standing there alone, crowned by a fan. A cord tangles its way between Albert’s hat and the back of one of his new mates via the uncirculating fan rendering their need for dialogue superfluous, given such a manifestation of electrical connectivity symbolising their unspoken accord.
“Albert’s been let into the boys’ club, the first, the one and only Indigenous Australian allowed in, but no-one’s talking to him, he’s not part of the forum, he’s not in the team.”
- I try to discover voices that don’t
- …seem to pop up on Goodreads.com.
- Julian Bull is one of these voices.
- The best way to find gems like Aussie Albert
- …is to read literary reviews:
- Overland (Aus), Dublin Review (Ire), The Sun (US),
- The Malahat Review (Canada)
Essays: Quicksilver N. Rothwell

- Author: N. Rothwell
- Title: Quicksilver (6 essays)
- Published: 2016
- Trivia: Awarded Prime Minister’s Literary Award Non-fiction 2017
- Trivia: Short List Multicultural NSW Award 2018
- List of Challenges 2018
- Monthly reading planning
- Lists of Awards
- #DealMeIn2018 Jay’s Bibliophilopolis
Australia: Essay nr 2: Quicksilver
- Theme: crossing the sacred line
- European colonization upset the balance of the Australian Aboriginals.
- Missionaries imposed their belief – colonial administrators imposed order.
- The title of the book Quicksilver represents the ancestral powers that were stirred.
- “…once the sacred, that quicksilver, has been put in play
- …you can never tell where it will go.”
Australia: Essay nr 4: The Mirror that Creates
- Theme: outsiders
- Rothwell sketches Australia’s foundation
- …its physical and mental development.
- It is often the European visitors – D.H. Lawrence or Bruce Chatwin
- …who are sensitive to the landscape.
- Australia served as a refuge for writers from Europe shattered by WW II.
- “Outside eyes determined what Australia…..was felt to be.”
Australia: Essay nr 5: What lies Beyond Us
- Theme: the landscape behind the landscape
- This was the most interesting essay in the book.
- I learned about landscape literature by Eric Rolls
- …his book (1981) won many prizes but it is impossible
- to find a copy of the book… A Million Wild Acres !
- I also I learned about the ionic Australian poet Les Murray.
- He celebrates country virtues in his poems and
- …has me baffled at times by the metre he uses.
- This is part of his uniqueness…. metre always matters.
- He has been tipped to win a Nobel Prize in the future!
Conclusion:
- My notes include just a few thoughts
- ….that impressed me in this book.
- I really enjoyed Nicolas Rothwell’s analysis
- …of culture and identity in this collection of essays.
- If there is a weak point
- ….it would be Rothwell’s ’round-about’ way of approaching
- …the central issue in his essay.
- It took a dosis of patience on my part
- …to keep reading when I thought:
- “What does this have to do with Australia?”
- But I persevered and enjoyed Rothwell’s thoughts.
Quarterly Essay Australia: ‘Without America’

- Twitter: @burns_nancy
- Trivia: List of challenges 2018
- #DealMeIn2018 Jay’s Bibliophilopolis
- Trivia: Read Australian writers: Hugh White
Read: Quarterly Essay, vol. 68; White, Hugh, 28 November 2017 (Australian)
- This is worth the time it took to read….2 hrs!
- Essay: , ‘Without America: Australia in the New Asia’
- Hugh White is Professor of Strategic Studies
- ….at the Australian National University.
- Stop assuming that USA is going to dominate Asia forever
- Stop assuming that USA will keep Australia safe.
- China is now so strong and ambitious that USA under Trump..so weak
- that USA will cease to be a significant player in Asia.
- Australia must prepare itself for this transformation.
- I loved White’s explanation of two world powers put their rivals to the test!
- “classic power-political salami-slicing”
- “…each slice of the salami might be insignificant,
- Washington looks weak if it can’t or won’t stop China taking
- …one slice after another, and China by contrast looks strong and resolved…”
- OUCH!
- “Rex Tillerson has proved to be the worst secretary of state in living memory,
- ….and the overpraised General James Mattis in Defense
- ….has failed to bring coherence to the administration’s strategy.”
- WHAT?
- Who would have thought that Indonesia will be a
- ..VERY POWERFUL country, second only to China?
- Thank you, Hugh White for opening my eyes….about China and Indonesia!!
- I think TRUMP should put this essay
- ‘Without America’ in his bedside night table….
- …his TBR!!
- Conclusion:
- 40 years ago Australia managed
- …a ‘post-alliance’ transition with Britain.
- Now Australia’s task in the next few years will be
- …doing the same with America!
- China’s rise is a fact and isn’t going away.
- This will require Australia to rethink a lot of things,
- to make some hard choices, and perhaps
- to pay some heavy costs.
- Excellent… #MustRead essay!
Quarterly Essay: Enemy Within

- Twitter: @burns_nancy
- Trivia: List of challenges 2018
- Trivia: #DealMeIn2018
Read: Quarterly Essay, vol. 63; Watson, Don, 16 September 2016 (Australian)
- I’m trying to read a back-log of essays…and this one caught my eye!
- This essay was written BEFORE Trump won the US election.
CONCLUSION:
- This is one TOP NOTCH piece of writing!
- I am amazed how Don Watson (Australian) has written such
- …clever an insightful observations about a
- …complex and chaotic American political landscape.
- Strong point: D. Watson is well read.
- He uses this information…to support his conclusions.
- The Tragedy of American Diplomacy (W. A. Williams, 1988)
- America’s War for the Greater Middle East (A. Bacevich, 2016)
- Strong point: writing style
- Don Watson is cheeky and at times irreverent.
- For example calling John Foster Dulles
- …and his brother Allen door-kickers
- …hitmen for the cause of US world supremacy. (ouch)
- Watson gives us a refreshing look
- at the divides in America (Blue-Red sates)
- zooms in on the ‘purple state’ of Wisconsin,
- the circus we call the US elections,
- the TV news media and the candidates.
- …especially the appeal of Bernie Sanders!
- Strong point: Best chapter: 6
- Watson makes remarkable comparisons between
- Trump’s campaign….and fascism
- …fanning the flames of rhetoric to win votes.
Last thoughts:
- I am very, very impressed with Don Watson’s essay.
- He is one of Australia’s foremost writers and intellectuals.
- There are so many Australian writers who we must discover!
- After reading this thought provoking essay
- …I think of a phrase I saw on the internet:
- Obama is the America…it thinks it is
- Trump is the America….it knows it is.
Here are a few gems:
- US:
- The United States is a concatenation of sulky tribes provincial
- …ignorant and seething with ambition…. [OUCH!]
- US TV NEWS:
- The pundits are not there to judge the quality of thought or action
- …An election is a horse race and
- …no one cares what horses are thinking. [OUCH!]
- TRUMP vs TV NEWS:
- Donald Trump understands the news channels
- better than they understand themselves.
- His “outrageous” tweets push people toward the media
- …and the media towards him.
- He dominates the news.
- He wins every day.
- Even when he loses, he wins! [HOW TRUE….]
- TRUMP vs EVANGELICALS:
- Americans want a president through whom God can act.
- But as well as the right president
- …it must be the right god.
- Trump understands this too.
- [DE TOCQUEVILLE…wonders has TRUMP read my book?]
- Personally…I don’t think Democracy in America is on Trump’s TBR.
- BERNIE SANDERS:
- Sanders never had to worry about an “image problem,”
- …because he didn’t have an image.
- When he appeared on television he did not look like
- …a man in search of a camera;
- …more like a man just retired
- …who stumbled in on a talkshow [LOL]



















