#Non-fiction: Say Nothing

- Title: Say Nothing
- Author: P. R. Keefe (1976)
- Genre: narrative non-fiction
- Published: 2018
- List of Challenges 2020
- Monthly reading plan
- Title: from the poem “Whatever You Say, Say Nothing” by Seamus Heaney
- #Obama’s reading list 2019
- Trivia: Winner 2019 National Book Critics Circle Award for nonfiction.
Introduction:
- The books concerns the Troubles in Northern Ireland
- …beginning and ending with the 1972 murder of Jean McConville.
Strong point:
- This is a very good book if you want
- …to know what it felt like during The Troubles
- …fear, omertà, code of silence title: “Say Nothing”.
- Keefe’s writing style is cinematic.
- — POV meant to simulate the experience of watching a movie.
- —setting, characterization, structure
- — create visually dynamic scenes
- London car bombs, ch 11
- force feeding Dolours and Marion ch 14
- gruesome hunger strikes (Dolours, Brendan and Bobby Sands)
Strong point:
- Keefe realizes that this book has its ‘edgy sides’, unpleasant to read...
- …but he also knows the only way to keep the reader (in this case…me)
- engaged from cover to cover it to use the “glue” of empathy.
- Dolours is mentioned 525 x (…thank you Kindle).
- I keep reading because I feel connected to Dolours
- …interested in her plight.
- …wondering what makes a girl become so revolutionary, political?
Conclusion:
- Hook: 1972 – chapter one as Jean McConville is dragged
- out of her house
- ….and thrown in a van by masked thugs.
- Her body was finally found 43 years later in 2003.
- The crime remains unsolved.
- This book was slipping away… from me but
- …on page 50 things started to change!
- Chapters alternate between the Prices sisters (Dolorus and Marian)
- ..and the McConville’s (Arthur and Jean….and their children)
- …top-ranked IRA Gerry Adams and Brendan Hughes.
- This is a lot to take in
- ….it is almost numbing to read about The Troubles.
- Many key players are dead,
- Brendon ‘the Darkie’ Hughes (1948-2008)
- James Martin Pacelli McGuinness (1950-2017)
- Dolours Price (1950-2013)
- …one is still living Gerry Adams (1948)
- …Irish republican politician who was the
- …President of Sinn Féin until 2018.
- He advocated for a political movement to run
- parallel with the armed struggle.
Last Thoughts:
- I learned more about a period in recent history
- I hadn’t known much about.
- It was a loose framework for a historical look at
- …some of the everyday people who got caught up
- in the violence of the IRA.
- It’s a sobering book
- It is a hard read so…
- …prepare yourself to be drained
- ….when you close the book.
- #HistorySeenInRearViewMirror
After the Count…should have won Walkley Award 2020

- Author: Stephanie Convery
- Title: After the Count
- List of Challenges 2020
- Monthly reading plan
- Trivia: Shortlist Walkley Award 2020
- Trivia: Shortlist Nib Literary Award 2020
- #AWW2020 @AustralianWomenWriters
Introduction:
- When young and fit professional boxer Davey Browne died in the ring
- pummeled to death in front of his family and friends…
- it was the result of a perfect storm of
- …incompetence by members of the boxing fraternity.
- For journalist Stephanie Convery it hit home hard.
- She was beginning her own serious boxing training
- …when she heard the news.
- After the Count investigates:
- the title fight
- the aftermath of David Browne Jr’s death
- interrogates the culture and history of boxing
- its gender dynamics
- the visceral appeal of the ring and
- the inherent contradictions of a violent sport
- …that refuses to face up
- the consequences of that violence.
Conclusion:
- Strong point: excellent ‘hook’ …hits you with a 1-2 punch
- Strong point: excellent introduction revealing the structure of the book.
- Strong point:
- The very personal perspective written by a woman
- ..boxing and trying to come to terms
- ..with the fear head injury and permanent brain damage.
- …this makes the book tremble
- …in my hands (pg 83-84) she must have a CT and MRI scan.

- Strong point:
- Ms Convery alternates between x-examination at
- inquest (lawyer vs neurosurgeon) with her personal visits to GP
- and hospital for CT scan.
- This makes for intense reading that keeps
- this reader glued to the page.
- Strong point:
- Ms Convery…adds her own questions to the narrative:
- How many deaths attributed to the boxing sport?
- How knocks to the head change the brain?
- What is the link between concussions sustained in
- contact sports and
- CTE (Chronic traumatic encephalopathy)?
- This is a neuro-degenerative disease which causes severe and
- irreparable brain damage, as a result of repeated head injuries.
- Her research reveals the shocking facts.
- Eye-opener:
- It wasn’t unusual for boxers to break their hands
- in fights and to punch on regardless! (pg 76)
- Strong point: pg 253-261
- The reader follows Ms Convery during
- her Fight Night for her final grading
- as boxing student at Joe’s Gym.
- Just amazing listening to her thoughts as she
- prepares herself explaining
- ….that with all the knowledge she as
- learned during her research for this book about concussion
- as she tries to pull herself away from the sport…
- …it draws her back somehow.
Last Thoughts;
- What a powerful book….I am absolutely bowled over by
- Ms Convery’s investigative research, her coverage of the death inquest
- and most importantly her conclusions in the last chapter.
- Sometimes the shorlisted book is BETTER that the prize winner!
- This is the best non-ficton read of 2020!
- I guess I’ve saved the best for last!
- #MustRead
Books read:
- Fallen – Lucie Morris-Marr
- City On Fire: The Fight For Hong Kong – A. Dapiran
- Penny Wong – M. Simons
- The Altar Boys – S. Smith
- Hazelwood – Tom Doigt
- We Can’t Say We Didn’t Know – S. McNeill

#Non-fiction The Anarchy: East India Company

- Author: William Dalrymple (1965)
- Title: The Anarchy: East India Company, Corporate Violence, the Pillage of an Empire
- Genre: non-fiction
- Published: 2019
- #Obama’s reading list 2019
- List of Challenges 2020
- Monthly plan
Conclusion:
- Enjoyed parts of the book but found it crushingly detailed.
- If you don’t know much about India or its history…
- you will be buried under a pile of names and
- places that will mean nothing to you.
- After 25% …I just skimmed the book, excruciatingly boring.
- It was a soulless history an 200 pages too long.
- Doesn’t anyone have a red pen at Bloomsbury Publishing?
- You can dislike a book for any variety of reasons,
- but in the end it comes down to a matter of opinion,
- and opinions can differ from person to person.
- So, if you are interested in history
- …read the book and perhaps you might like it.
- I did not.

#Non-fiction Walking With Ghosts (memoir)

- Author: Gabriel Byrne (1950)
- Title: Walking with Ghosts
- Genre: memoir
- Published: 2020
- List of Challenges 2020
- Monthly plan
- #IrishEyesAreSmiling
Conclusion
- I did not expect this!
- Gabriel Byre writes his memoir as a poet
- …so lyrical, so close to the heart
- …making observations about his hometown
- …and youth that I said to myself:
- “Oh, yes….I remember!”
- Think back to all those quirky people you knew and
- …saw through child’s eyes:
- the barber with a twirling red/white striped cylinder on his store
- the cobbler who knew exactly where your shoe was.
- And I was mesmerized by the wall behind him filled with
- saint’s holy cards.…the rock stars in his life!
- …the chic millinery lady who sold frilly hats and gloves
- Byrne: “Sometimes in those days I felt that I might crack and
- …break apart with joy.”
So vivid….in “my little hometown USA”
- smell of geraniums as you brushed against them
- …Dad’s go to flowers when nothing else would grow.
- smell of boot polish at the cobblers…I can’t remember his name but he spoke with an accent.
- smell of fish with glassy eyes laying on a carpet of crushed ice at the R&D Fish Market.
- swiveling on the red-vinyl bar stools at Mahoney’s Pharmacy/soda shoppe…cherry Coke!
- the hiss of irons and a fog of steam…in Simonetti’s Dry Cleaning
- dark, spooky Chinese laundry in Derby…wanted to get out of there fast!
- fat tummy’s in tight white aprons the butchers at Fulton Market..chopping bone and gristle.
Conclusion:
- This is a MASTERPIECE !!
- …the type of book that lifts your spirits!
- Just let yourself go….and embrace the memories that
- Gabriel Byrne’s memoir will awaken!
- Walking With Ghosts should be enjoyed while
- …sipping a glass of wine preferably in front of
- …a roaring fireplace on a cold winter’s night.
- #BravoGabrielByrne
#NonFicNov 2020 Week 4 New to My TBR

The Netherlands…..summer morning 2020
Week 5: (Nov. 23 to 27) – New to My TBR (Katie @ Doing Dewey): It’s been a month full of amazing nonfiction books! Which ones have made it onto your TBR? Be sure to link back to the original blogger who posted about that book
- Here is my list of YOUR books
- ….that I want to read (TBR).
- It’s important to read outside of your experience,
- …outside of your time,
- …outside of your comfort zones.
- That is the most important take-away #NonficNov!
- Note: 35 % of the books are by authors of color (*)
- Thanks to the readers for sharing your best non-fiction!
- Thanks to hosts…
- Leann of Shelf Aware
- Julz of JulzReads
- Rennie of What’s Nonfiction
- Katie @ Doing Dewey
Jinjer@The Intrepid Arkansawyer
- *Blue Highways – William Least Heat-Moon
- Notes To Myself: Essays – E. Pine
- Spillover D. Quammen
- *Our Time Is Now – Stacey Abrams
- *The Best We Could Do – Thi Bui
- *March Trilogy – John Lewis
Kate @BooksAreMyFavoriteAndBest
- Say Nothing – Patrick Radden Keefe
- This Is Going to Hurt – Adam Kay
- Indianapolis – L. Vincent, S. Vladic
- Labyrinth of Ice – B. Levy
- Piano Lessons – A. Goldsworthy
- Hearing Maud – J. White
- The Burning of Bridget Cleary – A. Bourke
- Ship of Fools – Fintan O’Toole
- The End of Novel Love – Vivian Gornick
- In My Father’s Court – I.B. Singer
- The World in the Whale – Rebecca Giggs
- *A Month in Siena – Hisham Matar
- *The Biography of Resistance – M.H. Zaman
- Clean – J. Hamblin
- *The Vanishing Half – Brit Bennett
- *The Nickel Boys – C. Whitehead
- A Train in Winter – C. Moorehead
- How To Talk About Climate Change in a Way That Makes a Difference – R. Huntley
- The Body Keeps Score – Bessel v.d. Kolk
- An Anthropologist on Mars – Oliver Sacks
- The Common Good – R. Reich
- *Civility – S. L. Carter
Liz Dexter @Librofulltime
- *Slay In Your Lane – Yomi Adegoke and Elizabeth Uviebinené
- Forced Out – K. Maxwell
#Non-ficiton The Altar Boys

- Title: The Altar Boys
- Author: Suzanne Smith
- Genre: non-fiction
- Published: 2020
- #NonFicNov
- #AWW2020 @AustralianWomenWriters
- Trivia: Shortlist Walkley Award 2020
- Trivia: Suzanne Smith is a six-time Walkley Award
- award-winning journalist.
Introduction:
- My goal of reading the shortlist of the Walkley Award 2020
- is almost completed. There was just one more hurdle to jump:
- I did not think I could bare yet another book about sexual abuse
- in the Catholic Church.
- Having read Cardinal (Louise Millligan 2017) and
- Fallen (Lucie Morris-Marr 2020)..I had had my fill.
- Now, The Altar Boys….seems to approach
- the subject from a VERY personal angle.
- Ms Smith decided to write her book after
- …a dear friend Steven Alward
- committed suicide January 2018.
- She spent six years investigating the
- …Maitland-Newcastle diocese in New South Wales.
- She developed strong personal connections with
- …several abuse survivors.
- one was even an ABC television colleague.
- In her new book The Altar Boys
- Ms Smith focuses on one heroic whistle-blower priest.

Conclusion:
- I tried to take notes….but was immediately
- drawn into the book that I forgot time and place.
- Ms Smith raises new questions about the suicides
- of three former victims of Catholic clergy child sexual abuse.
- In her book, Smith details what happened
- …in Glen Walsh’s life after his abuse,
- when he became a priest himself in the Maitland-Newcastle diocese.
- What more is there to say?
- This is just heartbreaking to read.
- One justice during a priest’s trial summed it up:
- the inside top of 3 Marists Schools protected the brothers/priests
- who taught young vulnerable children,
- It was “an organised criminal activity.”
- Now having read three books about sexual abuse by
- clergy in Australia I can conclude this book was the most confronting.
- Many children endured violence and abuse in silence
- Thanks to journalists, psychologists, law enforcement
- ….the veil of secrecy is slowly being lifted.
- Many Catholics don’t go to Church now because it
- is rapidly losing its credibility, but many still keep their beliefs.
- #ExcellentJournalism

#AusReadingMonth2020 Penny Wong

- Author: Margaret Simons
- Title: Penny Wong
- Published: 2019
- Bingo card SA
- List of Challenges 2020
- Monthly reading plan
- #NonFicNov 2020
- #AusReadingMonth2020 @bronasbooks
- #AWW2020 @AustralianWomenWriters:
Conclusion:
- My first impression was in the book’s preface:
- Ms Wong was reluctant to cooperate with Ms Simons.
- She told Ms. Simons she was an introvert
- …and suffered from prejudice and therefore
- …developed a closely guarded internal life.
- Penny Wong’s main motivation for
- …entering politics was to combat racism.
- Racism formed her in more ways than she is aware.
- I wonder if Ms Simons will be able to “crack this hard nut”?
- Researching a biography involves a lot of borrowing and persuading
- anecdotes, interviews (…or not, partner Sophie, mother Jane).
- Political party history (Labor) and public records are the ingredients
- Ms Simons used to fill in the gaps.
- Getting hold of personal information
- …about Penny Wong was a herculean task.
- Yet Margaret Simons persevered to give the reader a
- book that is …
- .…lucidly-written, logically-structured, and convincingly argued.
- The Shark Poem (pg 11) that Ms Wong wrote as a 12 year old gives
- …the reader a glimpse of one of Australia’s most popular politician:
- Shark poem:
- …the way it adapts
- …moves cleanly through its environment
- …the way it inspires both fear and respect.
- …that is Penny Wong.
- Despite these accolades….it was a very difficult book
- to read b/c of my lack of knowledge about
- the nuts and bolts of Australian politics.
- Ms. Simons did an honorable job with the little
- input she had from Penny Wong.
- Backstory – 5%
Education – 5%
University student politics – 5%
Personal relationships – 1 %
Australian Politics – 85%
#NonFicNov week 3 Be/Ask/Become the Expert

Week 3: (Nov. 16 to 20) – Be The Expert/Ask the Expert/Become the Expert (Rennie of What’s Nonfiction): Three ways to join in this week! You can either share 3 or more books on a single topic that you have read and can recommend (be the expert), you can put the call out for good nonfiction on a specific topic that you have been dying to read (ask the expert), or you can create your own list of books on a topic that you’d like to read (become the expert).
- Something has to change in USA.
- Racism isn’t worse…it is just getting filmed!
- …George Floyd killing on 25.05.2020.
- I can only start to understand what has to change
- …by educating myself….by reading.
- I concentrated on books about race and racism in 2020.
My thoughts:
- I’ve made a decision about 2021.
- I want to read AS MANY books AS I CAN
- by minority authors.
- Fiction, memoirs, poetry, non-fiction,
- ….(auto)biography, short stories essays, plays...
- I want to discover just how white our reading world is.
- White authors reign in book reviews, bestseller lists, literary awards
- ….and Amazon.com recommendations.
- I was stunned when I read that cultural commentator Roxane Gay discovered
- in a survey of New York Times articles published in 2011
- …that nearly 90 percent of the reviewed books were authored by white writers.
- People of all cultures and backgrounds have valuable experiences
- …and universal ideas to share.
- We all stand to gain when those voices are heard.
- So, if you have ANY good reading suggestions by minority writers
- (African-American, African, Indonesian
- …Indian, Chinese, Hispanic, Native American, Aboriginal…etc)
- ...please leave the book title in a comment.
- …much appreciated!
Books read:
- Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption – Bryan Stevenson (#MustRead)
- Just Us – C. Rankine (#MustRead) The BEST book on this list!
- The Fire This Time – editor Jesmyn Ward (#MustRead)
- The New Jim Crow – Michelle Alexander
- Between the World and Me – Ta-Nehisi Coates
- Tears We Cannot Stop – M. Dyson (#MustRead)
- Democracy In Black – E.S. Glaude jr.
- My Vanishing Country – B. Sellers
- How to Be an Anti-Racist – Ibram X. Kendi
- Brown is The New White – Steve Phillips
- Heavy – Kiese Laymon (#MustRead….but I advise it as audio book)
- We Live for the We – D. McClain
- Caste – I. Wilkerson
- White Too Long – Robert P. Jones (eye-opener about white supremacy!)
TBR: American reading list:
- A Promised Land – Barak Obama
- The Tradition – Jericho Brown (poetry)
- Tough Love – Susan Rice
- The Collected Essays of Ralph Ellison – R. Ellison
- Citizen: An American Lyric – Claudia Rankine
- A Fool’s Errand – Lonnie G. Bunch
- Girl, Woman, Other – B. Evaristo
- Beloved – Toni Morrison
- They Can’t Kill Us All – Wesley Lowery
- Nobody Knows My Name – James Baldwin
- Their Eyes Are Watching – Zora N. Hurston
- I Wonder as I Wander – Langston Hughes
- Think Like A White Man – Nels Abbey
- Begin Again: James Baldwin’s America and its Urgen Lessons for Our Own – E.S. Glaude jr.
- I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings – Maya Angelou
- Homie – Danez Smith (poetry)
TBR Australia Indigenous
- Archie Roach – Tell Me Why: The Story of My Life and My Music
- Chris Sarra – Good Morning Mr. Sarra
- Stan Grant – Talking To My Country
- The White Girl – Tony Birch
- Claire Coleman – Terra Nullis
- Rachel Hennessy – The Heart I Swallowed
- Shireen Morris – Radical Heart
- Tara June Winch – The Yield
- Witi Ihimaera – Mãori Boy
- Anita Heiss – Am I Black Enough?
- Larissa Behrendt – Finding Eliza
- Bruce Pascoe – Dark Emu
- Nakkiah Lui – Kill the Messanger
- Miranda Tapsell – Top End Girl
- Selina Tusitala Marsh – Tightrope (poetry)
Obama’s 19 favorite books 2019
- I’m reading 9 of these books before deadline 01.01.2021
- ….9 by white authors.
- Per 01 January this exciting challenge begins!

#Non-fiction City On Fire: Hong Kong

- Title: City On Fire: The Fight for Hong Kong
- Author: Antony Dapiran
- Genre: non-fiction
- Published: 2020
- #NonficNov
- Trivia: Long-listed for the Walkley Book Award 2020
UPDATE: 24.11.2022
- I don’ know how much news about China is a ABC news, MSNBC or CNN
- …but this is a potential flashpoint for China now!
- One of the most underreported
- stories right now is China’s failing Zero-Covid policy.
- Cases have surged to record-high levels (30 000 daily cases) &
- 420 mln people are back in lockdown. Lockdown…that is a powder keg with a short fuse!
- This violent protest is from the Foxconn iPhone factory in Zhengzhou
- …APPLE is very worried their phones will not make be found under USA Christmas trees!
- Xi Jinping can look very impressive at G20 ….but he has a lot of problems at home!
UPDATE: 20.11.2022
- Books about China politics have impacted the way I see the world.
- These books have opened my eyes to the geopolitical importance of decisions
- made by China and …countries who must deal with China.
- This all makes my “JAW-DROP” because if you don’t feel it yourself
- NEVER forget China…is a nation on a ‘long-term’ mission!!
- The world must prepare for its influence on us all!
- I wonder if anyone asks for Dapiran’s book in the bookstore or library?
- There is NO BETTER way to prepare than to read and educate yourself.
- I would recommend Anthony Dapiran’s book as the best place to start.
- He is a journalist and he creates an impressive narrative to explain the
- …flashpoint we know as Hong Kong.
UPDATE: 31.01.2021 – article in the Guardian
- Leave Hong Kong….before it’s too late!!
UPDATE: 25.11.2020 – article in The Guardian
- Carrie Lam praises new security law.
- Hong Kong is a gaping hole in the security of the mainland!
- NO OPPOSITION…can you imagine living there?

Introduction:
- Antony Dapiran is a Hong Kong-based writer and lawyer.
- His book chronicles the Hong Kong protests of 2019.
- I am just curious what is going on in Hong Kong
- ….behind only the TV images I have seen.
Conclusion:
- Back round information about Hong Kong that
- passed me by while I was concentrating all my
- attention on USA politics
- 2019 – impeachment Trump
- 2020 – elections USA.
- Strong point:
- reveals the the strategy, tactics of the protestors.
- Strong point:
- writing is concise....with important analysis:
- Remember:
- Beijing knows if it deploys troops to Hong Kong
- …that would mark THE DEATH
- of Hong Kong’s status as in international
- …financial hub!
- Chairman Xi would snuff out hopes of his “China Dream”.
- Strong point:
- This book reveals the face of Chinese power to the world!
- It seems I have taken my eye off the ball during 2020
- …blinded by US politics.
- New rule: read more about China!
- Don’t skip the headlines in the newspapers
- …because change is coming sooner than you think!
- #Taiwan is in China’s cross-hairs!
- Read your newspapers.
- …and watch the slow and steady
- …squeeze as Beijing first isolates Hong Kong to weaken it
- …then pushes it towards integration with the mainland China.
- How long will this take?
- #MustRead non-fiction book
- …..history in the making!
Last thought:
- Do not let ‘short lists’ influence your reading...
- I thought this book was 100 X better than
- the books designated as
- …potential winners Walkley Award 2020 on 20 November.
- Fallen by L. Morris-Marr
- We Can’t Say We Didn’t Know – S. McNeill
- Is the book a prize winner?
- No, unfortunately it has not been shortlisted
- ….but it should have been on the shortlist!! !
- This book will help you
- …follow the news into 2021 about Hong Kong!
- #ThisProblemIsNotOverYet
November HK News: update
- What state power has been doing is to try and subdue
- the few organizations that remain independent.
- daring and professional. (free press)
- They really want to close down this environment of open information.
- July 2020: draconian national security law
- 12 Aug 2020: Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy La arrested.
- who is owner of …one of Hong Kong’s most-read newspapers.
- 12 November 2020: Hong Kong opposition resigns en masse
- after members ousted from parliament.
- The end of “One State, Two Nations”

If your interested….my notes on the chapters
Chapters:
- A Death in Taipei
- ….very obvious ‘hook’ chapter
- …with ref to a gruesome murder!
- The March of One Million – 09 June 2019
- Protests over proposed legislation that could have
- allowed residents to be extradited to China
- where they could face possible torture and unfair trials.
- Blocking the Bill –
- flashback 2014 the ‘Umbrella Movement’
- comparison with 12 June 2019 demonstration
- The March of Two Million – 16 June 2019
- Protesters have mainly focused their anger on Lam,
- who had little choice but to carry through dictates issued by Beijing,
- where President Xi Jinping has enforced increasingly authoritarian rule.
- Be Water!
- Ref: Bruce Lee — philosophy”
- ‘Be like water making its way through cracks.
- Do not be assertive, but adjust to the object,
- and you shall find a way around or through it.
- Storming the System – “..the (extradition) bill is dead”..or is it?
- Reclaim Hong Kong! Revolution of Our Times! – protest 21 July 2019
- The Right to the City – protests move to airport
- and shopping malls on 26 July 2019
- …protestors weaken urban infrastructure to service their protest!
- Blooming – Art/graffiti posed as much as
- challenge to Beijing’s authority in the city
- …as the black-clad youth in the streets.
- The Battle of Sheung Wan – 28 July 2019
- Upper Street (the English name for Sheung Wan)
- a peaceful and quiet neighborhood with hints of cosmopolitan
- London and a bit of Chinese grit.
- Protests shape shift into clashes in different districts
- …constantly changing the frontline!
- Protests resemble Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables!
- Act 1: build barricades
- Act 2: clash with police
- Act 3: protestors ‘being water’ and disappear
- Curtain falls: …police face an empty street.
- Strike! – 05 August 2019
- …..general strike compared with 1967 strike
- …was not very successful b/c of no support from the unions
- Things Fall Apart – bloody Sunday, 11 August 2019
- VERY GOOD CHAPTER…read carefully!
- …police use new tactic: disguised as protestors …suddenly turned
- …without warning on their neighbours in the crowd
- …stoking suspicion and paranoia.
- More airport protests, but the movement starts falling apart
- …because of lack of discipline.
- A Protest of Enchantment – 23 August 2019
- Hong Kong protesters join hands in 30-mile human chain.
- …and just as the clock struck 9pm…the people quietly dispersed.
- …a fleeting moment, an important enchanting statement.

- The End of Summer – 31 August 2019
- Police shoot pepper spray as they try to detain protesters
- inside a train at Prince Edward metro Station.
- This is the final breakdown between city and its police force.
- Most disturbing trend in 2019:
- the appropriation of the Hong Kong Police Force....by Beijing.

- One State, Two Nations – 04 September protest
- Resist! – announcement of
- 04 October curfew and…
- anti-masking law and…
- criminal charges for revealing personal details of police online
- ..this is called “doxxing”.
- Injunction: check people posting on internet (chat groups)
- …and service providers and server hosts.
- Many would now conclude…it was safer to stay silent.
- City on Fire – 01 October 2019
- A fire burns during an anti-government protest in
- Hong Kong on the 70th anniversary of the
- founding of the People’s Republic of China

- The Siege – 19 November 2019
- Police assault the Polytechnic University of Hong Kong
- PolyU has been occupied by protesters for several days.
- Police warned protesters they had until 22:00 to leave the campus,
- saying they could use live ammunition if the attacks continued.
- There were daring escapes: students running across rooftops
- …crawling through sewer system. A girl was helped by a Whatsapp
- …sent to her to guide her through a little-known gap in PolyU perimeter.
- The Silent Majority – 24 November 2019
- Hong Kong goes to the polls.
- Hong Kong’s opposition pro-democracy
- movement has made unprecedented gains.
- Despite fears the vote could be disrupted or
- cancelled over the unrest, it went ahead peacefully.
- NOTE: ….where is the opposition now?
- …See news 12 Nov 2020
- A Way of Live…. VERY GOOD CHAPTER…read carefully
- The question is now “How does it end?”
- Violence has been normalized…both state and street violence
- HK’s reputation is damaged….not an example of good goverance
- Visible lasting impact of the protests:
- HK has become a security state.
- HK is a city on the verge of a nervous breakdown.
#Non-fiction Sophie McNeill

Conclusion:
- The book felt like I was reading a Wikipedia page
- ….with a heavy dosis of pathos.
- You feel the emotions of sadness or pity
- which has come from telling the harrowing experiences people
- caught up in the Middle East conflicts.
- Pathos is used as a way to emotionally appeal to the listener or reader.
- You may like this book…..but it did not resonate with me.
- #WasteOfMyReadingTime
